The Stuttering Source
  • Blog
  • Forms/Brochures
  • Media
  • Resources
  • National Therapy Center
  • Contact

Is this stuttering? 

2/14/2014

5 Comments

 
Picture
I have been getting a lot of questions from SLPs and parents that all seem to center around the question "Is this stuttering" or "Does this warrant speech services?"  


Question:  
I am a school based SLP. I just screened a 7 year old girl. Her teacher was concerned that she might be stuttering. She is repeating whole words and phrases quite often. She also used some interjections such as "um". Her teacher has never heard her repeat or prolong sounds. Is this really considered stuttering if a child is only repeating words and phrases? I have been looking on the internet, but most children either repeat syllables or sounds as well as words or else they don't repeat whole words as often as this student. 

Answer: 
You're correct in thinking that whole word and phrase repetitions are considered "typical disfluencies", however, if done excessively (both in frequency and in number of repetitions per word or "iterations") they aren't so "typical" anymore. Considering a teacher came to you about this, I'd say this is most likely occurring enough to interfere with the normal flow of communication and therefore warrants attention.  

You also have to consider that she may be using interjections (ex. um) to mask stuttering. The question is if she omitted "um" would she then present with sound repetitions, blocks or prolongations? Sometimes interjections are used as "tricks" or "starters" and although initially they seem helpful, they cause children to have to do a lot of "mental gymnastics" to get a message across.  This is exhausting/frustrating and has the potential to result in word/situational avoidances as the effort to mask stuttering exceeds the motivation to speak. It is so important to look at other aspects of communication, in addition to the frequency/type of stuttering, when deciding if therapy is warranted. Percent stuttered syllables simply doesn't give us the full picture, especially as children get older! I recommend assessing for secondary behaviors(physical tension and struggle associated with a stuttering moment), word/situational avoidances, impact on participation in social/academic settings, feelings associated with stuttering/speech and overall communication abilities.  I also suggest looking at the child's rate of speech and articulation of multisyllabic words. Is she aware of her disfluencies?  Excessive "typical" disfluencies is sometimes a sign of the fluency disorder, cluttering. 

Once you look at all these other aspects of communication, the decision to qualify for services should become clear! As a parent, if you have any concerns it is best to follow your gut and seek advice from a speech pathologist!  

Does anyone else have a similar situation with their child or a child on their caseload? What has helped you determine if the child does, in fact, have a fluency disorder and furthermore decide whether therapy is necessary?  
5 Comments
Brooke Leiman link
7/30/2015 01:02:09 pm

Just to wanted to add to this previous post that if a child is exhibiting excessive nonstuttered disfluencies but is not showing physical tension/struggle, awareness of stuttering, etc. it is possible that what you are observing is not stuttering but rather is developmental disfluencies or language formulation disfluencies. Nan Ratner wrote an article for SFA that I suggest looking at

http://www.stutteringhelp.org/child-isnt-fluent-is-it-stuttering-or-something-else

Reply
Jordan
9/10/2015 03:08:53 pm

Is there a resource that states the actual number of percent syllables stuttered which would be considered typical?

Reply
Brooke Leiman link
9/10/2015 06:30:32 pm

Researchers typically identify children who stutter as those who have 3% or more stuttering-like disfluencies. So "typical" would be 2 or less. If you include nonstuttered disfluencies, anywhere between 8 and 10% or more total disfluencies would be considered a fluency disorder. So "typical" would be under 10% when including typical disfluencies in the count). One article you might be interested in reading is:

Tumanova, V., Conture, E. G., Lambert, E. W., & Walden, T. A. (2014). Speech disfluencies of preschool-age children who do and do not stutter. Journal of communication disorders, 49, 25-41.

Lisa link
4/13/2017 02:07:43 pm

I have a similiar student whose interjections don't proceed any disfluencies. How should I approach treatment/ideas?

Reply
Brooke Leiman
4/13/2017 04:55:23 pm

Lisa-

I think you first need to determine the underlying cause of those interjections. It sounds like you don't think they are stuttering-like..have you provided receptive/expressive language testing?

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Brooke Leiman MA, CCC-SLP, BCS-F Director of the Stuttering Clinic at National Therapy Center
    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    May 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    March 2016
    May 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    August 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Posts

    All
    Advertising
    Avoidance
    Famous People Who Stutter
    Feelings/Emotions
    Other Fluency Disorders
    Parents Of Preschoolers
    Parents Of School Aged Children
    Social Situations
    Speech Pathologists
    Speech Tools
    Students
    Teens And Adults

    Picture
    Picture
    DISCLAIMER: The purpose of this website is to act as an educational aid and address common topics associated with stuttering.  It is not intended to replace the need for services provided by a licensed speech pathologist who can tailor treatment to an  individual's needs.  
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.